York, Pennsylvania

What Does a Truly Great Sandwich Taste Like to You?

At Custom Subs, every sub is built from scratch — fresh-baked rolls, locally sourced produce, and premium meats sliced to order. Your sandwich, your way.

Explore the Menu Find Us
17401
York, PA
Fresh
Daily Ingredients
Your Way
Built to Order
Scroll
Interior of Custom Subs with sandwich counter
Fresh vegetables and ingredients for subs
Fresh baked bread rolls
Preparing a custom sub sandwich
Our Story

A Sandwich Worth Stopping For

Located on W Market Street in the heart of York, Custom Subs was founded on a simple conviction: a great sandwich shouldn't be complicated. It should be honest — quality ingredients, proper technique, and the freedom to make it yours.

We source our meats from trusted suppliers, bake our rolls fresh, and prepare our vegetables each morning. No shortcuts. No compromises. Just a properly built sub, the way it ought to be.

Sliced to Order
Premium meats, never pre-packaged
Fresh Daily
Produce and bread prepared each morning
Built Your Way
Choose every ingredient, every topping
Local & Proud
A neighborhood staple in York since day one
The Experience

More Than a Sandwich — It's a Ritual

There's a rhythm to a properly built sub. The crack of the roll, the layering of meats, the precise drizzle of oil and vinegar. At Custom Subs, we take that ritual seriously — because the details are what separate a good sandwich from one you'll remember.

Fresh Ingredients, Every Day

Vegetables are prepped each morning. Bread arrives fresh. Nothing sits past its prime — that's our promise.

A Neighborhood Favorite

From lunch crowds to after-work stops, Custom Subs is where York comes for a sandwich that delivers every time.

Made With Care

Every sub is assembled by hand, with attention to balance and flavor. No rush, no shortcuts — just a well-made sandwich.

Custom Subs sandwich counter with fresh ingredients on display

"The best sandwiches don't need a long story. They just need good ingredients and someone who cares."

Visit Us

We're Right on Market Street

Stop by for lunch, a quick bite, or to grab a sub for the road. We're easy to find and always ready to serve.

Address

380 W Market St
York, PA 17401

Phone

(171) 791-6370

Call for catering & orders

Hours

Mon – Fri 9am – 8pm
Saturday 10am – 7pm
Sunday 11am – 5pm
Map showing Custom Subs location at 380 W Market St, York PA

380 W Market St

York, PA 17401

Get Directions
Is this your business?This is my business